Costello Real Estate Logo
$1,295,000
305 Sumter Avenue, Carolina Beach, NC 28428Listing ID 100565975

305 Sumter Avenue, Carolina Beach, NC 28428

Active
Not In Subdivision
Time on site: 224 days • Last updated: 4 hours ago
Property Type
Property Type
Residential
Property Sub Type
Property Sub Type
Single Family Residence
Bedrooms
Bedrooms
4
Bathrooms
Bathrooms
3
Square Feet
Square Feet
1,841
Acres
Acres
0.17
Days on Site
Days on Site
224
Cooling
Cooling
Central Air, Heat Pump, Multi Units
Heating
Heating
Heat Pump, Electric, Forced Air
Year Built
Year Built
1979
Garages
Garages
2
Parking
Parking
Electric Vehicle Charging Station(s), Attached, Covered, Concrete, Off Street, Tandem, Underhouse

Six bedrooms, four bathrooms, and approximately 2,607 square feet of combined living and additional space, all just blocks from the beach in the heart of Carolina Beach. Completely renovated from top to bottom, this coastal retreat offers two distinct living spaces, beautifully curated interiors, an incredible backyard designed for entertaining, and the flexibility to enjoy as a second home, full-time residence, or income-producing investment. With 1,841 square feet in the main residence and an additional 766 square feet in the lower-level apartment, the property offers a unique opportunity to accommodate guests, create separate living arrangements, or explore rental income potential, all under one roof. Located just a short stroll from the Spartanburg beach access, Carolina Beach Lake, and the weekly Farmers Market, the best of island living is right outside your door. Inside, thoughtful renovations blend coastal character with modern design. Original shiplap pairs beautifully with updated LVP flooring and tile throughout. The kitchen features new appliances, soft-close cabinetry, under-cabinet lighting, open shelving, and a stunning custom-made dining table that anchors the space. Custom trim work and a built-in landing zone add thoughtful finishing touches. The main residence features four bedrooms and three bathrooms, including a spacious primary suite with a walk-in closet, oversized walk-in shower, and private balcony. Two beautifully designed bunk rooms and an additional guest bedroom provide plenty of options for hosting friends and family. Downstairs, a fully equipped two-bedroom, one-bath apartment offers its own private entrance, kitchen, living area, and outdoor patio. Whether used for extended stays, guest accommodations, or potential rental income, this additional space creates flexibility that sets the property apart. Separate laundry facilities accessible to both levels, an outdoor shower, and generous storage add to the home's functionality. And then there's the backyard. Designed to make the most of Carolina Beach living, this outdoor retreat features a custom-built firepit, expansive patio, covered entertaining area wired for an outdoor TV, and a custom storage shed. A new aluminum staircase with Trex decking connects the spaces, while improvements including new fiber cement siding, two HVAC systems, new water heaters, and a metal roof completed prior to the current ownership add lasting value. Six bedrooms, two distinct living spaces, and endless possibilities just blocks from the sand. Whether you're looking for a coastal getaway with room to host, a property with income potential, or a beautifully renovated home that offers something beyond the traditional floor plan, 305 Sumter Avenue is an opportunity worth exploring.

Property Information

Property Details

Location

Address
305 Sumter Avenue
County
New Hanover
City
Carolina Beach
Zip Code
28428
Subdivision
Not In Subdivision
School District
New Hanover
High School
Ashley
Elementary School
Carolina Beach

Interior Features

Beds and Baths

Bedrooms
4
Full Bathrooms
3

Building

Building Information

Square Feet
1,841
Year Built
1979
Construction
Fiber Cement, Wood Frame
Foundation
Other, Pilings
Roof
Metal

Financial

Special Conditions
Standard

Property Taxes

Tax Year
2025
Kristen Lueck • Compass Carolinas LLC
Source: Hive MLS
Hive MLS logo

IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS. All information herein has not been verified and is not guaranteed. ©2026 Hive MLS LLC.

For corrections to this data please contact Brytecore MLS Support.

579516785